Archive Page 173

Malling around

We had some idea of mussels by the ocean, after climbing the tallest man-made structure in the world, but we ended up in the Dubai (do buy) mall the entire day. We tried out the metro which turned out, at the end of the day, not a good deal because it is not synchronized with the mall closing. Taxis are cheaper, maybe because they are driven by people who don’t earn that much.

The Bourj Khalife had just opened when we travelled through here in January this year. At that time it seemed more of a symbol of Dubai extravagance than anything else. But today we had the full experience: from vision to reality, the architectural ideas, drawn from a flower that looks like a trillium, sketched then drawn, then competed, redesigned, tested and finally built. There were pictures of the mason and the master architect, the art designer and the carpenter, the project manager and the package manager – all smiling into the camera, life size, presumably after the project was completed. I am sure they weren’t smiling all throughout the design and construction phase.

At the top of the structure, or at least the highest point where tourists are allowed, we watched the dusty skies. Computer screens showed the view for day and for night, as well as the life view, which wasn’t all that clear, so we opted for the programmed view from another day, clearer than today.

All the time we were so high up there I thought of the World Trade Center on 9/11 and the people jumping to escape the inferno for another form of death. I was glad to be back on the ground.

We found a fast food fish place (Nordsee) that actually had baguettes with herring – not exactly like Dutch herring but close enough. After that we malled and malled for hours, testing macchiato here, ice cream there, marvelling at the variety of choices, the freedom of walking around uncovered, the absence of guns, blast walls, razor wire and sand bags and the cleanliness. With the amount of money generated from war, poppies and international aid, Afghanistan could surely create something like this?

When we had tired of malling we watched a local movie about arab men with too much money, colliding with a poor Indian cab driver dreaming of a Bollywood career and an eastern European flight attendant in trouble. It ended OK for most of them except the spoiled rotten Arab men, one died and the other was wrecked by guilt and drank himself silly on forbidden whiskey which made his dad very mad; but then he found religion which, I presume, made his dad very glad.

After dinner we found a cold beer-serving Thai restaurant that looked out over the Bourj fountains. For the price of putting up with the moist 36 degree air, we had a front row seat to a most spectacular musical water ballet, with a new show every 20 minutes. We watched it from one side with our Thai food, and then later from the other side of the lake with coffee and dessert. So that was Dubai, Holland is next.

Someplace else

I spent about 3 hours in the office, more than I had intended and less than was needed, but it was the start of my vacation and I had reached that point where I was too exhausted to be of any use to anyone.

I wonder whether my tiredness was exacerbated by Dexter Filkins’ reports in the New York Times about the tangled mess us foreigners have gotten ourselves in. It creates an uncomfortable frame for our work and our belief that we may be making a difference for ordinary Afghans.

We boarded the Safi flight to Dubai without Captain Courtney – we are on different schedules, unfortunately. Across the aisle a woman with a bag that said ‘Statistics Changing Society.’ I thought of Katie and her eye for good and bad statistics. I wondered what a member of the Royal Statistical Society was doing in Afghanistan but never asked. She looked as tired and exhausted as I felt.

The flight was among the most uncomfortable we remember – seats so closely together that even my knees touched the seats in front; all seats leaning backwards against the instructions of the flight attendant, whether you had touched the recline button or not and the heat from Dubai that went all the way to Kabul and back.

We are now in Dubai in an inexpensive hotel we found on the internet which, to our surprise, has an Irish pub with ice cold beer. We ordered fish and chips and ate them, under the eyes of multiple TV screens, watching white robed Arabs play pool. We could have been in London, or Dublin; and we definitely were not in Kabul anymore.

Home-made and balanced

Axel and Katie cooked up a storm in the kitchen while I was chipping away at my before-leave-to-do list. There was the promise of fermented grape juice, one of the remaining bottles Katie brought, but only if I had completed my homework and pressed the ‘send’ button on my handover notes.

I spent the entire morning interviewing applicants for a deputy Program Manager position that is on my side of the organogram. It is a new position that requires travel to the provinces. I was told women wouldn’t apply for such a program. But two did. One couldn’t be bothered to come to the interview so I regretfully crossed her off the list but the other did show up and impressed me greatly; and not just me. She came out on top of a fairly strong field. I asked her how she works with older male doctors. ‘Gently,’ she replied.

When I interview people for positions I listen for their theories of changes – their underlying, and often unconscious beliefs and assumptions about how change happens, how people change. We are, after all, in the change business.

The contrast in theories of change were major. There is the one that assumes a good analysis, a needs assessment and then a plan is all you need. But the woman thought differently: you listen and find out what they know that you need to know; you present yourself as a learner and then you move softly along. These were not exactly her words, but the examples she gave illustrated the idea.

People often joke about gender balance, or rather the absence of it, as if it is something funny or ordained. I sometimes counter this with a remark that the infiltration has begun but I have to be careful because gender balance in practice remains a touchy issue. There is a double standard applied to women at work that my mother would recognize instantly. She’s dead now but if she could, she’d shake her head.

The result of Axel’s and Katie’s cooking was a delicious Pad Thai, including home grown mung bean sprouts, homemade tofu from the Korean restaurant and home-cranked pasta prepared yesterday by our housekeeper and cook. Only the shrimp were missing but we are too far away from the sea.

It’s now bed time and time to pack, so something has give. I think the packing will be delayed till tomorrow. The plane to Dubai isn’t leaving until late in the afternoon.

Life

The one and a half year old child of one of my colleagues died after pulling a pot with boiling water off the stove and over himself. The hospital couldn’t save him. The men in our office went down for a brief prayer together. These rituals happen frequently, but mostly for older relatives who passed away; people whose time had come, not little children.

Another colleague found out his friend was kidnapped in one of the eastern provinces; the ransom is enormous. Some people don’t survive this. People are praying for a good ending.

We picked up our directors’ meeting against the backdrop of this anguish and worry. Our own small worries and anguishes about the project and our performance seemed insignificant for a moment, until life resumed. Here life resumes all the time.

Perched

Today the physical therapy crowd was happier than last week; there was less moaning and more chatter. We compared notes on injuries in shoulders, knees, feet and arms. Some women are on the same schedule as I am, so we are starting to know each other. I am finding out who is the mother, the sisterm the daughter and what caused the injury. My rudimentary Dari is coming in quite handy to satisfy my curiosity

I had another painful deep tissue massage – self inflicted because last week’s massage left me pain free for the entire week, something I had not realized until I was asked.

Judy has arrived from the US for a short course on good consulting. I registered all our provincial staff because I want them to be less focused on ticking off activities from a to-do list and more on the results that these activities produce (and if they don’t, do something different).

Judy and I had lunch (baguette au jambon – imagine that!) at the French Pelican restaurant and caught up on not having been in the same office for 8 months, besides preparing for this week‘s activities. I think this time I was a little better prepared than I was for Anddy’s workshop last week.

I completed my first Dari reading book. It ended well with the two protagonists learning to read and write in Dari and then teaching their wives. It’s a literacy primer so this was not much of a surprise. My homework for the next few weeks is to read book number 2. I can’t wait to learn what the second primer in the series might be about.

For dinner Sabina came over. Sabina reports to a German radio station and was finally let out of the Intercon hotel, having followed the Peace Jirga from the 5th floor press center’s perch. She watched the rockets that were lopped, unsuccessfully, at the jirga tent, while a German military officer provided on the spot expert commentary.

Fruit and grit

The weather pattern in May and June goes like this: crisp mornings, blue skies, no wind. Slowly, over the course of the day the wind picks up and swirls the dust of Kabul around and deposits it on all of our horizontal surfaces. Everything is gritty.

Leaving Axel behind at home to finish a writing task before the end of the day, Katie and I visited Babur’s Gardens this morning, early, before the crowds arrived. Where all the lilacs were in bloom during my previous visit, now it was the turn of the roses, and cherries ripening on the trees.

We were lucky to stumble upon an exhibit entitled ‘Afghanistan Observed 1830-1920.’ It is an extraordinary peek into Afghanistan as it was observed by several famous British military artists, photographers, lithographers, watercolour painters and draftsmen.

The exhibit was mounted in the Queen’s Palace, in the beautifully restored harem with its high walls that kept the women safe from the men who didn’t owe them. Today there were lots of men in the harem. They crowded around us, watching us as much as the pictures.

Katie and I had a salad and mango smoothie lunch at the Flower Street Cafe before making a last trip to Chicken Street (we will both be gone from Afghanistan next Friday). On our way home we shopped for fruit and vegetables, picking up an odd vegetable that we looked up on the internet. It appears to be a prickly cucumber; we don’t quite know how to prepare it yet.
Tomorrow I will take it to my language teacher for further instructions. I discovered Afghan leeks; they look more like the Thai chives we have growing in our Manchester yard and taste more subtle than the American and European leeks.

We also loaded up on the many fruits that are now available in the market: tiny white apricots from Iran, melons, lemons plus freshly made yogurt and butter. After three days off from work (for us as well as for our staff), we have finished all the meals prepared by our cook and are now cooking ourselves; Nasi Goreng tonight, Tacos and Fajitas tomorrow. After that the cook will return and cook again.

We are learning from the foreign media what the Peace Jirga appeared to have produced, against most expectations: a consensus about negotiating with the Taliban, on the condition that the Afghan constitution is not violated (i.e. right of women). This is not welcomed by everyone, especially not by those Afghans who want to move into the 21st century. How all this will play out in real life is far from clear.

Winners and losers

We watched The Message (with Anthony Quinn) last night, about the birth of Islam. We had seen it earlier, dubbed in Dari, on the Prophet’s birthday in March but now I have it in the original English version. I had not understood then that the Afghans would play a movie produced by sinful Hollywood about their prophet but this time I saw the opening credits and an announcement that the film had been certified as authentic by religious scholars from Al Azhar University in Cairo and that Hollywood had agreed not to actually show Mohammed.

It is a long movie with much fighting and preaching. One by one Axel and Katie peeled off to go to sleep and although I tried to, I finally gave up to before the movie was over. This didn’t matter since we already knew the ending. In the centuries that have passed since then many things have not changed much in this part of the world, except maybe that the unveiled women in the movie are now veiled.

After being cooped up all day today in the house we escaped to a local Korean restaurant where they serve beer and great food. A few colleagues joined us, including Pascal who just arrived from Haiti in a very roundabout way, only hours after the rockets landed near the jirga tent. What a start! Pascal is a young doctor who won an award last year that he competed for with many other young MSH professionals in memory of our three MSH colleagues who died here in Afghanistan when their plane hit the mountains on a wintry day early 2005.

This year one of my young female staff applied after much goading from my side and pleas with her husband to let her try. When we returned from dinner I found out she was awarded the fellowship. Now we have to figure out how to make her trip out of Afghanistan work. It is not obvious but I am convinced we’ll find a way. I like these kinds of challenges.

After dinner we settled in front of the TV and watched ‘It’s Complicated,’ which was just what I needed after a long day in front of my computer.

Peace and rockets

We heard about the rocket attacks on the Peace Jirga via sms from our security folks but when we watched live coverage of the Jirga it was as if nothing had happened. The insurgents are bad shots, people say here and shrug their shoulders. But 100 meters away from the tent is a little too close for me. We are probably about 5 to 10 miles away from it all and didn’t hear a thing, other than the beep-beep from my cellphone that there was a message.

I watched the jirga open, the speeches and the patriotic songs with the ethnicities of singers carefully chosen so as not to offend anyone. Row after row of dignitaries, male and female, were sitting in respectful attendance. It looked very boring to me.

We are in lockdown until the whole thing is over, I believe at the end of Friday. That sucks because it means we can’t go on our usual Friday jaunts around town. And so we keep ourselves busy with housework, work-work, cooking, watching TV, preparing for our trip to the US, OBTC and deleting emails.

I was happy to see pictures of Tessa and Steve paying their respects, on behalf of all of us, to the ancestors. The planting of geraniums (maybe it was something different this year) at the Magnuson graves is an annual ritual that always ends with a vodka toast to them; we drink some and dribble some on the graves. And then it is Memorial Day, a day that is meaningless here; in Bamiyan I forgot all about it. Which soldiers would you honour here when you never know who are the bad and who are the good guys until much later and even then many people will disagree?

Comings and goings

Last night we had dinner in a bunker. Not really a bunker but a living space carved out underneath a container, outfitted as a guesthouse. It was warm, said the owner, to be underground during the cold Bamiyan winters. But frankly, I found it a bit depressing.

We sat for a couple of hours in that place while our host was cooking an extravagant dinner, on his own, without help from wife (who was in Kabul) or staff. I think he has none. We did see the driver show up with the rice, so I guess he was called in for help.

We at the dinner in another house in the same compound that opens up to the runway on one side and to a spring and trees on the other. The back side of the house sounds lovelier than the runway side but it was dark and we couldn’t see.

The runway in Bamiyan is one of the few level surfaces in Bamiyan. In between the sporadic arrivals and departures of planes, it is used by the population as a footpath, a crossing or a road. Just before planes land and take off an official car travels up and down the gravel runway to clear cars, motorcycles, donkeys, bikes and people off the surface to make sure there are no nasty accidents.

This morning we travelled back to Kabul. The trip that took us 6 hours and 3 landings and take-offs only took 26 minutes on the way back. With that Katie completed a circle over half of Afghanistan.

We are back in Kabul with its restrictions and polluted air. Tomorrow, when we get up, we will not see the snow-capped mountains and green meadows or hear the gurgling brook; instead we see the still and stinky water of one of Kabul side rivers in back, over the barbed wire, as well as the commander’s house with his army of armed attendants and officers who do nothing but cleaning cars and their boots all day. The little snow that was left on the mountains surrounding Kabul appears to have melted while we were away.

I watched the end of Anddy’s assignment. He got things stirred up and now leaves us with the difficult task of maintaining that enthusiasm. But the team he worked with is psyched and ready and now knows a new tool for participatory organizational assessment, to supplant the consultant-driven assessments.

Maria Pia is also leaving tomorrow because the office has decided to close down in case the Peace Jirga that is supposed to start tomorrow triggers attacks; and even if these won’t happen, then there are the traffic jams caused by whole parts of the city being roped off. We get to stay home tomorrow while Anddy nurses his first beer in Dubai; we get to stay home again the day after, when Anddy and Maria Pia are welcomed back home. And then it is weekend and someone else is arriving.

Talibanned

We are taking advantage of a brief moment of internet access at the hotel while there is electricity, in between our travels around Bamiyan and dinner at our colleague’s house. This is the same colleague who tried valiantly to get to a conference in Geneva, two months ago. Waiting for our turn we sit on the roof while the light is dimming over the valley. It is breathtaking at any time of the day.

We visited a comprehensive health center that I will forever remember because of its spotless but rudimentary bathroom (a hole in the ground, all cemented and reeking of chlorine). Health center or hospital bathrooms are rarely that clean even though one would think they are.

Next to the health center is a school: girls in the morning and boys in the afternoon. The girls, all in their black dresses and white veils clumped around us – we were the excitement of the day. Katie was like the pied piper with at least thirty girls following her every move. I got to sit at a disk with Malika and Rahela and practice writing their and my name in neat little schoolbooks. The eagerness and energy of these girls make you feel a little better about Afghanistan’s future, assuming they get to continue their schooling beyond a few grades and are not married before they reach puberty.

We followed the Community Health Supervisor to the house of a community health worker (male) in a small village outside the provincial capital, which itself is a small village. We were received in his father’s compound which he shares with his brothers and sisters and their offspring. He served us lunch which consisted of traditional bread, large bowls of yogurt with several spoons in each and plates with fresh butter. It was my kind of lunch, all dairy, only cheese missing. It was a feast in a poor man’s house and probably a considerable sacrifice.

Back in the provincial capital we visited the vaccination office and learned about how they manage the data flow and the multiple requests from everyone and his brother to see results. They have good results but the graphic representation of these didn’t really do their results justice.

Next we visited the provincial hospital where we met the nursing team that is working on lowering infection rates. I was happy to find a very smart and vocal nurse among the team with a great sense of humor. She belongs to a pool of female Aga Khan University (Karachi) alumns who I keep running into. They give me hope about Afghanistan’s future, if the men would only let them. She talked about the Taliban with irreverence and referred to it as a boring time. When we mentioned that we enjoyed our freedom here in Bamiyan and were somewhat constrained to office and house in Kabul, she quipped that now it was our turn to be Talibanned.

We toured the brand new maternity waiting home, a collaborative effort between the New Zealand Provincial Reconstruction Team (PRT), local citizens who bought the land and UNICEF that will provide staffing. The lovely house, one long architectural curve sweeping around itself to come full circle (I was later told that it was designed by a Dutch (male) architect, engaged by UNICEF, who meant it to be shaped like a uterus.

The uterus building was just completed and awaiting its furnishings, equipment, water and electricity. Fifteen very pregnant women, each with a care taker, can lodge inside this uterine place until their baby arrives. This will free up the 15 hospital beds these women are now occupying. Such maternity waiting houses are being opened in other provinces as well. I was supposed to have witnessed one such opening in Badakhshan early March but the helicopter didn’t fly.

And finally we had a meeting with the provincial health team to digest our very full day. It was a complex meeting in that much was in Dari and I can follow about one third but not enough to really get myself understood well; things get lost in translation. I still have to mull over what our conclusions were and what we can and cannot do here in Bamiyan. Lots of opportunities and lots of constraints. More about this later. Photos also later. Katie has a real camera and is making awesome pictures.


April 2026
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930  

Categories

Blog Stats

  • 140,872 hits

Recent Comments

Sallie Craig Huber's avatarSallie Craig Huber on Rays for real
Lucy's avatarLucy on Probabilities
Olya's avatarOlya on Cuts
Olya Duzey's avatarOlya Duzey on The surgeon’s helpers
svriesendorp's avatarsvriesendorp on Safe in my cocoon

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 78 other subscribers