We are all sad about the misfortune of our grandcat Cortez who got hit by a car and is in the emergency room up in Western Massachusetts. Sita compared his post accident experience to ours to which Axel replied, “love and care of those who love him will heal him – it worked with us.”
Tonight is Axel’s turn to be exhausted but he is not sure he should turn in in our sparkly new bedroom – it still smells of paint. We put the air purifier on at full power and waiting for the little blue window to say ‘very good air quality.’ It did that two nights ago in the Solter Suite but we know now it was lying.
In our staff meeting this morning we spent a lot of time talking about people’s concerns about moving into the ministry. “We work in this organization (meaning MSH) for a reason,” several people said. In the ministry one can be lucky and have a good boss with integrity and commitment or you can get the opposite. But the good boss can be replaced by a bad one quite suddenly and you won’t have any recourse and nothing to protect you. People are cynical, sometimes very cynical, about the motives of civil servants, even those who are well paid, and rightly concerned about the arbitrary power of those above them.
The challenge of working with civil servants who are poorly paid (most of them) and ‘building their capacity’ is that they don’t necessarily want their capacity built. Workshops and training courses are a nice way to supplement one’s meager income. Boycotts, while holding out for higher per diems and other goodies that come with training, has become a favorite pastime. For us, who are well paid, committed, motivated, well supported and protected from arbitrariness by organizational procedures, checks and balances, this sort of attitude drives us nuts while we also realize it is totally understandable. That’s why we have ‘minimum wage’ in our part of the world.
The idea that work should be self-actualizing fulfilling and intrinsically rewarding is not a universal concept and probably doesn’t apply to the underpaid civil servants. Work is toil – even Calvin said so.
A dear old friend and ex colleague has returned to Kabul as the chief of a project. When we first met 20 years ago she was an administrative assistant. I am thrilled to see her in this new position and actually got to see her at work right my office, negotiating with someone on her project about something he wanted and she couldn’t give. She was brilliant, he unhappy.
At SOLA only three girls showed up in my class – all three are Axel’s projects. I know the kind of lessons he teaches them and so I can see how they apply what they learn from him as we continue our very slow progress in Three Cups of Tea for young adults. One of the girls has trouble with long and short vowels. When she pronounced the word sheet with a short ‘i’ we did some practicing saying ‘sheet,’ ‘shit,’ and ‘shed.’ I explained the differences.
One of the girls had heard about the Mortenson controversy which led to a conversation about being ‘a critical consumer of information.’ But before I could engage with them about this concept they needed to understand the words ‘critical’ and ‘consumer.’ Armed with the dictionaries Axel bought for them I set them off on a race to get to these words. It is for them as difficult as it is for me to find a Dari word; you have to know your alphabet – which letter comes after which one.
Finally when they got all the words they put them together (Eater of judgmental information. Huh?). We contrasted the way Afghan kids learn to uncritically consume information from adults in authority position and the cost of that. Do they believe their teacher, the press? They looked a bit shocked when I told them that their future classmates in the US might actually argue with their professor or teacher about statements, opinions, view points.
We had fun with the words ‘barked’ and ‘snapped’ used in the context of impolite conversation. After my explanation of these words I had them try the bark and snap dialogue between Greg and his first donor on each other. It led to shrieks of laughter but little success. As always the class lifted my spirits – a good start of the weekend.

Recent Comments