Posts Tagged 'Cote d’Ivoire'



Harvest time

I have a different role now in this kind of ‘technical’ work as we call it at MSH. In the past I would be busy 15 hours a day, thinking, planning, goading, negotiating, giving feedback, preparing. But now all this is done by others. I have handed over the baton and it has been carried around the block several times, without me lifting a finger or a foot.

I had not thought a lot about this but this is of course how it should be: working oneself out of a job. What I also had not realized that moving further away from the action (on the balcony as Ron Heifetz would say) allows one to reflect while taking in a much bigger landscape.

And reflecting I do. I have time to read and reflect and connect. I have time for slow conversations with people, driven by curiosity rather than some force outside me that wants answers. I love it.

In short succession I wrote 3 blogs for my own page on our intranet. I have no idea who will read it, I have a just a handful of followers, but it doesn’t matter. It’s like a storage place for ‘aha’s or ‘déclics’ as the French call it. I will post some here as well. Stay tuned.

Marvel

Monday morning we had a brief meeting with the project director who just returned from his vacation, about our adventures in western Cote d’Ivoire. I produced a slide show with the main observations, mostly good. I congratulated him and his team on what they have created in that part of Cote d’Ivoire that is often peripheral to where the action is.

My colleague R. treated us to a wonderful lunch: grilled fish, a paste made from plantains and Atieke, two local starches. The paste looks a bit like playdoh but tastes better. The sauce was made from the peanuts we bought on Sunday. It is a little spicy, like the Indonesian satay sauce, and very filling. Because of that it is usually eaten at home,  at lunch or breakfast time but not at night.

And then we took to the road again, this time closer by, to a town called Adzope, just 100 km north of Abidjan. It took us a small two hours. We arrived at the ‘luxe’ hotel where we launched the very first workshop of the leadership development program in May 2014. This is why am I am here: to observe our leadership development program that has been cascaded down. Now third and fourth generations of trainers are preparing the next generation to take the lessons even closer to the base. I kind of lost track of the many generations and branches that emerged from that first leadership development program all those years ago.

Once again, probably because of my white hair, I got the royal suite. It is called the ‘Suite Merveille’ (wonder or marvel suite), where I stayed last time as well. It has a bath with the same faucet arrangement I marveled (indeed) about when I was here last: the faucet doesn’t extend all the way inside the edge of the tub and thus, when the water is turned on, it splashes in all directions except into the tub. No one seems to have bothered to change the arrangement. This is Africa, improvisation in the face of adversity to the Nth degree, even when this adversity seems to me such an easy thing to change. “Ahh, c’est la vie!”

We are in the same heavily draped room with an enormous, un-moveable boardroom table that looks like a race track – an elongated oval with a space in the middle. It occupies a good part of the room. It sits about 35 to 40 people around. But we are 50. Away from the table is a second row, consisting of well-worn auditorium chairs with small writing tablets hidden in the arm rests.

I remember the panic when I saw this room three years ago. It is so completely contrary to what I then thought we needed (and could not do without). Now, 3 years later I don’t panic anymore. I know the process carries itself even if the space is unsuitable. It is no longer my problem (ah the joys of ageing!) and the facilitators can draw on their own experience to make the space work, as we did last time. They remembered, placing extra chairs on the inside of the oval, making small group work possible.

Containment

Yesterday we completed our sweep through one of the regions in the western part of Cote d’Ivoire. We sat in on the last session of this round of the workshops in the leadership program at the hospital of Bangolo. We were seated on brightly colored plastic chairs in a small standalone meeting room on the hospital grounds. Here too there were no tables, though some people used another chair for that purpose. This team, which included two women (unlike the previous group), was made up of the hospital director, someone from the ministry of sports and youth, an NGO leader, a midwife and a couple more hospital staff.

There is a way of applauding, all across Francophone West Africa, that starts with a shout ‘clap one,’ at which command people clap once, followed by a ‘clap two,’ and then ‘triplet’ (pronounced the French way). People clap three times in unison and with their hands send the last clap to the person who merits the applause. This person then accepts the clap by bringing his or her hands, full of the clap energy, to his or her heart. In the first group we attended on Wednesday, they even had assigned a focal point for these ‘triplets,’ who periodically shouted out the commands. The second group we observed had little of this and the third group did a triplet just about every five minutes. It can get a little bit stale after hearing dozens of triplets, but no one seems to mind.

I was quite pleased with what I observed the last three days. The facilitators were trained by the people I trained back in 2014, and most had entirely internalized the concepts and tools they were sharing. The three teams are working on the containment of infectious diseases outbreaks to keep them from becoming epidemics; it is small scale and small victory work right now but that is because they are practicing new ways of managing and leading as they go along. The hope is that after we are gone, they will have changed the way they lead and manage and can tackle larger problems.

The team in Guiglo focused on bringing deaths due to meningitis down to zero; the team in Duékoué was looking at neonatal tetanus and the team in Bangolo focused on rabies. I remembered a district in Afghanistan that had followed the same leadership development approach and also focused on rabies. They were able to bring the number of people coming into the hospital with rabies to zero by getting rid of the dogs that carried the virus. They did this by engaging multiple stakeholders to work together on this public health threat. I am sharing their Challenge Model with the group here – as they are not focusing on the dogs themselves, which they probably should. In Afghanistan it was the lack of environmental hygiene in the market and around slaughter houses that had led to the rabies outbreak

We had our last meal at the same place we have eaten every night – grilled carp and atieke and a salad with, every day, less and less tomatoes and more and more onions. We are now buddy-buddy with the waitress, Estelle, who was dressed in long white and gold trimmed gown, an outfit fit for the Oscars. Maybe because it was Friday night and payday just happened a few days ago? In her gown she dragged small tables and plastic chairs to accommodate our wish of not being too close to the disco that we assumed employed her. The playlist was fabulous but better at some distance. She served us our drinks with a smile and entertaining conversations. When we made moves to leave she kneeled before me and extended her arms, a respectful way of saying goodbye to an elder, which I am in this part of the world . She called me  ‘mamie’  (grandma), which I am also.

Amenities

We observed the first day of the three day workshop that is the second in a series of four. We met in the same meeting hall that had been re-arranged, to my great delight, with a circle of chairs in the middle. I had introduced this notion to others some time ago, as a much better way to meet (one cannot work on a computer or check a cellphone when sitting in a circle without tables). The idea had trickled down to the next generation of facilitators. It was a new combination of faciclitators and participants, and so a bit stiff for the first part. But eventually thaw set in and the conversations became more animated and the learning began.

Having a workshop that is held, quite literally, in the middle of the hospital, is challenging as participants can be called out at any time for an emergency. The facilitators were scratching their heads on what to do about it. I suggested they stop scratching and give the job to the participants. That is after all the team that is supposed to learn about leadership.

The facilitators create a village and the group selects the name of the village, appoints the chief and notables, a ‘conscience horaire’ (time keeper), a treasurer for the fines that late comers have to pay, etc. The norm setting is a well-worn ritual all over Africa and has little to do with the behavior of people. This version, which I have only seen in Cote d’Ivoire, with its village and chief was at least Africanized. But it did have an entire enforcement system that I thought was too much like the way things are here with the emphasis on extrinsic motivation.

And then, like all the other norms I have seen over my career, immediately ignored. The only part that was respected was the role of the village chief, both as arbiter of divergent opinions and to open and close the day.

The leadership work that we do, and which few recognize, is about awareness. I believe that if you are not aware you cannot make choices. And so I pointed out that they had created a new norm, by ignoring the norms they created, and that was that norms don’t matter and that there are no consequences for breaking the norms. And now that they were aware of this they could either throw out the norms or find ways to stick to them.

At 4 PM the session was over and we drove to the next town and a new hotel. This one also had no power and also no water. It may be hard to imagine this, from one’s comfortable vantage point in the US (or Europe, or fancy hotels everywhere) that a hotel could run without water and electricity. It reminded me of my first month in Beirut, in 1976, after the fighting had stopped. We stayed in the Mayflower hotel and ate our peas and rice in the dark.

I was given the royal suite. A comfortable suite of rooms with an enormous bed, and several amenities that were useless because there was no electricity (two aircos, two TVs and a refrigerator). The bathroom was nice but without running water not usable. All would come back in due time we were told.  Insha’llah, I murmured. But water and electricity did indeed return and I slept comfortably and took a hot shower in the morning. The latter had to happen before 6AM because after 6 the water would be gone again until 10PM. One learns to adapt.

We ate with our colleagues on the side of the road, grilled carp, an onion tomato salad and hot salsa and atieke, the local starch, washed away with a cold beer. Life is good.

Coffee

We met for the morning in the city hospital after making a courtesy visit to the hospital director. He is not a medical doctor but someone trained as an administrator. There are not many places I have visited, especially not in Africa, where non-doctors are considered competent to head a hospital. My Ivorian colleague told me that those hospitals headed by an administrator are generally doing better than those that are not. I am not surprised. After all, hospital administrators are trained for the job. Doctors are not.

I once had a fierce conversation with one of the aged notables of public health in West Africa who could not imagine that someone who is not trained as a medical doctor could possibly direct a hospital. It is funny how the same premises (having been trained professionally) can lead to opposite conclusions. Only if you take a closer look at the premise can you see the false reasoning.

In the morning the entire zone was without electricity. Our hotel had a ‘groupe’ (a back up generator) but it was without gas and ‘la direction’ had not responded to the frantic calls from his un-empowered staff. And so we were without electricity until we checked out. We had some fantasy about a small cup of Nespresso. Many hotels now have the little Nespresso machine and for an extra 3 dollars (a Nescafe stick costs 1 dollar) you can have cup of espresso, if, and this is a big if, the electricity works and/or they have the little Nespresso cups to put into the machine.

Although the electricity had not come back, two small cups suddenly appeared and the waitress beamed with pride, happy to bring us what we had asked for. I noticed the absence of foam and tasted the coffee.  It was hot and brown but it was not an espresso. They had simply opened a Nespresso capsule (and went back to the kitchen to show the used capsule to prove that they had not just used powdered coffee), and poured hot water over the content. The result had little to do with what I had hoped to get and tasted pretty much the same as the Nescafe powder that comes in the sticks.  I suppose both kinds of coffee have ‘Nes’ in common. I negotiated the cost down a bit but congratulated them with their inventiveness. With unhappy clients like us and management that is impervious to customer requests or complaints, they are the ones who will ultimately suffer.

More than a thousand feet

On Monday morning there was a further split among the three of us; two heading west to Guiglo, an all-day ride, and the other staying for a few more days before heading out to Niger, on another assignment.

I do dread the long drives, but with someone to talk with in the back it wasn’t that bad. The roads are good except for a long stretch with holes in the asphalt that require a slalom approach. This is fine as long as there are no cars coming from the opposite direction. I avoid looking ahead. I look sideways to my companion or down and read.

We had lunch in a ‘maquis’ (small semi-open air restaurants with limited menus). I had a piece of boiled oily fish in a bitter eggplant sauce, not so great but tying me over until the evening meal.

At hotel Tam-Tam in Guiglo we settled into our rooms, having to step over centipedes that were crawling all over the place. I learned that when they sense danger they roll up in a tight coil that feel and look like a button. I know this because I stepped on one such coil with my bare feet and thought I had lost a button. I had not paid attention to where I put my feet.

The omnipresence of these centipedes explained why the sides of the bedcover were flipped over onto the bed, preventing my bed from crawling with these 2 inch long creatures the size and shape of garden variety worms.

Other than that the room was comfortable, with an airco that worked as long as there was electricity, which was there about half the time, and a comfortable centipede-free bed.

We had a brief meeting with the team of facilitators of the leadership program – some people I had accompanied as they embarked on their new roles, nervous, and confused at times 15 months ago, and others that they themselves had trained or who had been coached by my Ivoirian colleagues. My terms of reference included a ‘refresher’ and then observing the trainings at various hospitals, given feedback, advice and suggestions where needed.

I asked for the men’s input (there is not much of a gender balance here) and realized that I had made some wrong assumptions about the timing and modalities of this training. I revamped the agenda accordingly that night, taking advantage of the electricity being on, and carefully stepping between the bathroom and my bed to avoid the centipedes that came in in droves from the hallway.

Small change

We left Man at 7:20 exact. I had calculated that we would arrive in Abidjan around 3:30 PM (which we did). It’s a long and at times scary journey but I was in good hands with a competent driver.

Mid way, after four hours of driving we stopped at a little maquis, a simple local restaurant with a limited menu of local dishes. The driver checked a few to make sure they had a toilet, and we ended up at one that had a toilet where one didn’t have to roll up one’s pantlegs.

The local food is quite good and the least likely to provoke intestinal troubles, contrary to what most people think. I have not consumed any processed food for more than two weeks now and I feel great.

Too my great surprise we ran into the regional director who was one of my students a year and a half ago. I don’t know many people in Cote d’Ivoire and those I know are mostly in Abidjan (and a few in Man now). To run into a familiar face in the middle of the country seems a coincidence. But my colleague Rose doesn’t believe in coincidences. She gave me a book ‘Le hasard n’existe pas’ (chance doesn’t exist). I haven’t read it yet, but in this case I would agree. Not only did the regional director explain more about the death of his secretary, he also told me that all the districts in his region now use the challenge model and things are more systematic and organized, with better results. I knew that his district director who was part of our facilitation team in Man has transformed (not only herself but also how her team works) but now it seems all of his district directors operate this way.

After reading Congo I realize that ‘changing health systems’ may be a pipe dream as long as corrupt leaders set the tone. But at least at a local level, some things I have done have made a difference. It may not be sufficient on a global level, but it is good for them.

Victims

Compared to the birthday breakfast I would have had at home, this one here in Man was a bit below the grade, a quarter limp baguette, a vache qui rit triangle and a Lipton teabag dipped in warm water served by a surly waitress. But a week from now I will make up, no doubt, with a spectacular replay.

On the second day of the workshop the group struggled to formulate a measurable result related to better coordination. Not surprisingly, people came up with more meetings and more people at meetings. We pushed for better and more creative results, such as setting up local structures to improve emergency preparedness, but the general attitude is one of victim – we are low on the country’s political and economic ladder and we never get enough money.

People don’t like it when I push them to be more creative and become agent rather victim – this is after all a leadership development program. There is some comfort in being able to decline responsibility and blame others for problems.

This may all seem very theoretical from a distance but yesterday a young woman, secretary of the regional health director whose district director is with us, died in the region’s referral hospital after childbirth. She leaves behind her newborn and two small children. Everyone is very upset about this (though they also remark this happens a lot – as one could see in the maternal mortality statistics).  It seems that the handovers were not done well. When people act as individual professionals and are looking only at their own responsibilities when their task is done, this is what happens. Although lack of trained personnel is sometimes a cause for such tragedies, at this hospital there were enough trained personnel. Heartbreaking, over and over again.

I sometimes think that working in teams, taking on a collective responsibility for outcomes, and willingness to shoulder blame is the biggest challenge in countries where people either have lived in constant fear of getting lost in the crowd of anonymous poverty or are still close enough to be worried. It’s puzzling as I am dealing generally with the educated upper middle classes.

When I challenge the constant coming and going of people holding their telephone in front of them as if it pulls them out of the room, I am told these are urgencies. I count. “You had 10 urgencies today?” (this is not a doctor on duty). “Oui, it is my boss asking for information.” “Can’t you ask your boss to leave a message and you will call back during break time?” They look at me in shock. What, ‘contredire le chef?” Culture and poverty…it is going to be a long journey.

Questioning

In my profession it helps to be an extrovert. Usually I am energized  by people who are learning, or eager to work together for a common goal.  But today, during the break, I went upstairs to my room and made my own cup of Nescafe rather than standing in line for exactly the same thing, and since I am not eating any of the stuff that is served at break time (all contains processed sugar) why bother?  Maybe it is because I am tired of having one event after another and being surrounded by people all the time. Or maybe it is because I am getting to be more introverted as I am getting older. Tomorrow I will be a little older.

At lunch time we had a heated discussions – I have heard the arguments over and over. They go something like this:

Me: “Why are there no women in any of your teams?” At first they joked. “We did this express.” When I took their response serious, they became more serious: “Women don’t want to work in this part of the country.” “Why,” I asked. “Because of the crisis (=the contested presidential elections four years ago that dragged Cote d’Ivoire into a nasty civil war). “But that was many years ago,” I said.

We went a little deeper. “They don’t have the right credentials.” “Why,” I asked (why is a great word in my work).  “Because they are nurses and midwives (at least in the health sector).” Me: “There are no women doctors?” At our table is a female departmental director (a doctor). She and a representative of an international NGO contest what the men are saying. We ended up with this: “This is how things are ‘chez nous’.”

Me: “You are willing to put a doctor at the head of a structure? Especially if this person (usually a man in most countries) knows nothing about management or leadership, or for that matter good governance? And, therefore does a lousy job such as depressing morale, being a poor planner, not understanding teamwork or delegation at best or being toxic  at worst? Someone who wastes resources (including such highly valuable resources as human energy and goodwill)? You prefer doing that (failure nearly guaranteed) rather than considering putting someone in charge who has demonstrated her management and leadership capacities but who isn’t a doctor?” “Yes” they say, “because a nurse or midwife could not possibly supervise a doctor!” There you have it. Checkmate!

One of my favorite sayings these days is that we tend to generate most of our own problems. Sometimes people get very angry when I say that, but I ask them to consider the practical consequences of accepting this thesis: if you agree then you can do something about your problems. If you don’t accept it there is not much you can do, and you will have to live with all these problems of today and all those in the future. The latter are the complainers – I have met too many of them.

What our leadership development program does is reduce that number quite a bit – our current facilitators are proof. They have started to question a lot more than they did before and in doing so they become change agents. We are working on a critical mass of questioners and critical thinkers, though this will probably not happen in my lifetime.

Managing

The passport has surfaced and I should have it in my hands when I board the flight for Addis. Miracles happen and DHL sometimes messes up.

Today we distributed the tasks for the three day workshop that starts tomorrow. I will do very little as I have handed over the baton to the team from Cote d’Ivoire, a mix of MSH staff and ministry of health staff. That was my job and it is nearly done. There were some misaligned expectations of the local staff, our rookie facilitators who inquired about per diem and facilitation fees, a manifestation of the disease we have created called ‘perdiemitis.’ I invoked good governance by saying if there were written rules about that on government letterhead we would gladly pay. Of course no one can produce such a document.

We wrestled with French translations of several words that were invented in Anglophone cultures. Every country and every French speaker seem to have his or her ideas about which French word best represents these essentially untranslatable concepts. We use Leadership and Management instead of Direction and Gestion – there are nuances that get lost in translation. Try to translate stewardship!  We are having endless conversations about this.

The whole notion of andragogy is still alien to people. They have received a classic French education that starts with definitions. One of my new trainees was wondering why we are asking all the questions to participants, like this one “think of a time when you worked in a great and productive team? What made it great?” Luckily one of the people I trained a year and a half ago, the cohort that is now taking my place, explained patiently that it is all about discovery of what knowledge we already have inside us. Yeah!

In the meantime I am counting the days to leave this hotel, have a good massage and a pedicure. This will happen in Addis. I looked up the hotel we will stay in and it has a picture of two Ethiopian beauties smiling in their white towels in the hotel spa. Here, the closed I come to spa is the wrapping on the tiny guest soaps “Spa, les fleurs du coton.”

The hotel owner is apparently some sort of priest or evangelical on Sundays. He showed up in flowing white robes when we settled into our conference room last Sunday. Seeing him in his flowing robes reminded me of the chapter in the brilliant Congo book about ‘la bière et la prière. On Monday he was dressed in ordinary clothes with a ladies handbag crossed over his chest like a conductor, except conductors don’t have ladies handbags. In it is a calculator and probably money. He spends a lot of time calculating.

He doesn’t seem to take his management duties very serious. This morning he sat down in the restaurant watching TV while the curtain rail (including curtains) on one side of room had collapsed onto a couch but he didn’t seem to notice. He doesn’t seem to be in the least concerned about his surly staff, the state of the kitchen, the lax security (regarding personal possessions, not terrorists) and the quality of the breakfast.’


January 2026
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

Categories

Blog Stats

  • 137,083 hits

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 76 other subscribers